The Orange Country Supreme Court of New York has dismissed the lawsuit brought by Park resident Geoffrey Isles. Mr. Isles, representing Citizens To Preserve Tuxedo Lake and as Trustee of the Elene De Saint Phalle Irrevocable Trust, had brought a lawsuit against the Village, the Village Trustees and the Tuxedo Club. The lawsuit challenged the Tuxedo Club’s permit to restore eight docks and the Club’s right to maintain seasonal docks #2 and #3. In the Order dated September 11, 2007 the Court’s simple and elegant solution was to deny Mr. Isles’ claims on all accounts and to dismiss the case in its entirety.

View Judge William J. Giacomo ruling on the suit. (pdf, 150 KB)

 

back to top